Learner Voices in Teacher Development Sessions

I’ve learnt lots of things about education from working with teachers and students in Gaza. Like other areas of the world which are discriminated against, oppressed, and neglected, people in Gaza generally value education very highly. This is perhaps partly because studying hard is seen as a possible way out of the mess that the rest of the world has inflicted on the people of Gaza, and partly because, with nowhere to go, mass unemployment and not much to do in terms of leisure activities, studying is often the only thing that you can do to keep yourself active.

Although, I’ve worked with teachers and students from Gaza for about 7 years now, the first time I ever went there in person was only in April 2017.  This was to speak at an UNRWA, British Council conference, together with Hands Up Project trustee, Scott Thornbury. I learnt an important thing on that day about organising teacher development sessions  and it’s stayed with me ever since.  Scott was due to do a workshop called ‘My ten favourite speaking activities’ and mine was called ‘My ten favourite writing activities’.  Both sessions were very practical in nature and we’d planned to demonstrate the activities with the participation of the teachers who were there – which I guess is a standard way of working in TD sessions.

However, when we got there we found out that as well as around 200 English teachers, there were also about 40 eleven to fourteen year old learners of English in the room. We spontaneously decided that we’d get the learners to do the activities instead of the teachers wherever possible, and have the teachers observe. I think this worked really well for a number of reasons.

When teachers take part in activities which are designed for lower level language learners, they either have to pretend that they are lower level language learners themselves, or (more commonly in my experience) they do the activity as themselves, using all the language that they have available to them as fluent, or near fluent users of English. Neither of these situations is ideal in my opinion. If as trainers we’re demonstrating activities because they have the potential to promote language learning it’s far better that real learners of English do the activities so that this learning may actually happen. This also frees up the teachers to be able to observe the activity taking place and to reflect on its potential benefits.

scott with learners
Scott demonstrating a speaking activity at the conference with real learners of English

In next week’s post I’m going to share my experience conducting a remote theatre training course in Gaza in which there were 15 young learners of English and 10 teachers of English working together in the same room. Before I do that, I’d be really interested in hearing your thoughts about this.

If you’re a teacher trainer have you ever worked in this way or would you ever consider doing so? Is it feasible to do this in your training context? What other ways may there be of bringing the voice of the learners into a teacher development session? If you’re a teacher would you like to participate in a training session that included real learners or the voice of the learners more? Comments below please…

5 thoughts on “Learner Voices in Teacher Development Sessions

  1. I think learners’ voices are under-represented in PD sessions and ELT conferences. We are used to listen to what authors, trainers and publishers have to say about learning another language but we hardly consider what students know about learning, what they want to learn and how to do it. And we are missing the whole point of teaching.
    I’m going to present my master thesis in a few months which is precisely called ‘Students’ voices about English Language Learning at school and beyond’. 😊


    1. Thanks very much for your comment Mariangel. I would very much like to read your dissertation when it comes out. Are you going to publish it somewhere? Next year’s Hands Up Project conference will take place on Friday 17th April at UCLAN in Preston, and the theme that we’ve chosen is ‘Learner Voices’. There will be face to face and remote live lessons, learner performances, and experienced language learners reflecting on their experiences.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Hi Nick,
        My dissertation is in Spanish but I plan to write some articles in English. I’ll let you know when and where they will be published. Thanks so much for the information about the Hands Up project conference, where can I find more information about it?

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply to Mariangel Carreño Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s